Lil Piegal Pie Shelf

With over 30 varieties,

All made the old fashioned way,

Nothing beats the taste of a fresh-baked
Sweetie Pie!

Here are some of our most popular pies. You'll find a list of all our regularly offered pies at the bottom of the page with prices. We also offer Sugar Free & Gluten Free pies. And don't miss our pie making classes in the winter!

For our Chicago-Milwaukee Road Trip click the Truck: Truckin

You might want to read our review at Door County Navigator too!

Cherry

Our most popular pie, by far, is Cherry! With those tempting, tart Door County cherries and our simple wholesome pie crust, without all those syrupy fillers, these cherry pies will take you back to Grandma's kitchen.

Then there is our hallmark "mile high pie", the big Apple. Each pie is packed with 2 ¼ pounds of apples, our favorite of which is Jonathan Gold. How do we make them so high? Well that's our little secret. :)

Apple
Apple Caramel Walnut

Add the richness of caramel and the crunch of walnuts and you get our Apple-Caramel-Walnut Pie. A pie that virtually has its own fan club! There are five other great Apple Combos: Apple-Caramel, Apple-Cranberry, Apple-Cranberry-Walnut, Apple-Cherry and Apple-Blackberry to make your decision that much harder.

Many customers are crazy about our Threeberry Pie. The three berries are Blackberry, Blueberry, and Raspberry baked in three gorgeous layers. We also make straight Blackberry, Blueberry, and Raspberry Pies.

Threeberry
PeachRaz

Brand new in the berry department is: Berried Treasure Pie a great combination of Blackberries, Blueberries and Strawberries. Bruiseberry was supposed to be a joke pie, Black & Blue - berries, in honor of Tae Kwon Do acheivements. Now it is a hit!
Larry Berry combines all four!

This is another big favorite: Peach-Raspberry not to mention our scrumptious Peach Pie and our other Peach Combo: Peach-Blueberry.

PeachRaz
Strawberry-Rhubarb

For an old fashioned treat try: Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie a favorite any time, but especially in spring. For the more adventurous there is plain Rhubarb or just recently available Cherry-Rhubarb

Another legend of a pie is Pecan.
Oops! It looks like someone got to this one before the photographer. Notice that it's pecans all the way down to the crust! Rachel Ray mentioned this pie in 2005!

Pecan
Chocolate Pecan

As long as we're talking Pecan, we'll just have to mention our secret weapon: Chocolate-Pecan Pie. Better known around the shop as "Killer" Chocolate Pecan Pie. The eyes roll back and diners are known to go into a sort of reverie.

If you love those Tollhouse chocolate chip cookies, you'll love our Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie & Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie.
Look for three new regulars:
Custard, Packer Pie
& Chocolate Chess Pie

Pecan
Cutie Pies

All these tantalizing pies are also available in diminutive versions called Cutie Pies. They are just 5 inches across and delicious through and through.

If these regularly available pies are just not enough for you; we also have the option of Creme Pies. These are only available in our shop on a call ahead (usually two days) basis. In addition to the Lemon Meringue pictured, there are Chocolate Creme, Banana Creme, Coconut Creme, ....

Lemon

And don't forget the Pumpkin Pie!

Pies and Prices

There are six price levels for our pies depending upon ingredients, labor and demand.

            $16.00

Chocolate-Chip-Cookie     Chocolate-Chip-Walnut-Cookie

Chocolate Chess     Custard     Packer Pie     Pumpkin

    $18.00

Apple     Apple-Caramel     Apple-Cherry

Chocolate-Pecan     Pecan     Rhubarb

      $20.00

Apple-Caramel-Walnut     Berried Treasure     Blueberry

Cherry Rhubarb         Red White & Blue     Strawberry-Rhubarb

        $22.00

Cherry     Bruisberry     Apple-Cranberry     Apple-Cranberry-Walnut        

Peach     Peach-Blueberry     Peach-Cherry    

        $24.00

Blackberry     Larry Berry     Peach-Raspberry

Raspberry     Raspberry Cherry     Threeberry

Special Orders:

      $26.00

All other fruit pies not on the standard list, family favorites, etc. are available on request.
This may take a week or more to make them up. We love to get your input!

No Sugar Added: we make all our fruit varieties sweetened with Smuckers "All Fruit" jams!
No sucrose or table sugar.

We also carry a limited line of "splenda" pies.

We normally carry Cherry, Apple, Bluberry & Strawberry Rhubarb. For other flavors call a week ahead.

We also carry the four flavors mentioned in Gluten Free with a crumble top.

No we do not make a sugar free Chocolate Pecan Pie! (We've been asked!)

Creme Pies:

    $26.00

(please request two days in advance)
Banana Creme, Cocoanut Creme, Chocolate Creme, Lemon Meringue ....

Strange Slice

   

Slices                    

$6.00                    

For another $1.00 add a scoop of delicious vanilla ice cream from Malibu Moos (right here in Fish Creek!)
We also have pints available for $5.00.
There is always whip cream for $.50 extra.

Look for our shelf full of "Fresh Yesterday" slices at $3.00

      Cutie Pies

$10.00

Our five inch minis.
Available in virtually all our regular flavors.

Back to top .